My response to "The top 5 reasons why Windows Vista failed"

I just finished reading Jason Hiner's article on ZDNet titled "The top 5 reasons why Windows Vista failed." While I have plenty of criticism for Microsoft, I couldn't help but think what an incredibly biased article this was.

You can read the article here: http://blogs.zdnet.com/BTL/?p=10303

Either Jason Hiner fell off his rocker or he is cleverly trying to create the perception that Windows Vista is this horrible thing.

5. Apple successfully demonized Vista

Sure Apple has done a great job with their ads, but why are you comparing Apple ads to the demise of Vista? You only show the Enterprise adoption rates which are ALWAYS slow and I am quite certain were impacted very little by Apple. I think if you compare the consumer markets you might have a more accurate idea of what is really happening.

 

4. Windows XP is too entrenched. I agree, but is this a surprise for an OS that has been around since 2001? Microsoft screwed up in my opinion by waiting sooooo long between XP and Vista. Also, what research do you have that says all netbooks will be running XP and that somehow netbooks are going to take over sales of normal laptops / desktops? And how did you predict that netbooks will never have the power to run Vista?

 

3. Vista is too slow - Really? What year is this? I noticed your benchmark link was from 2007. Sure you may need more resources to run it, but wouldn't Windows 98 fly on a P4 or Windows 95 fly on a P3 (Assuming it would operate). Vista is quite fast on my machine. I would understand if you were trying to upgrade your old machine to Vista, but isn't this really the start of a new platform, really meant to run on new computers? If you are going to say XP is faster than Vista, why don't you elaborate? Don't you think you need to consider that most drivers at release time may not have been tuned as well as they are now and that future performance will only increase on Vista, most likely far surpassing XP in gaming and other intensive areas? Isn't Leo Laporte's Ultimate Gaming Machine running Vista 64 because that was the consensus of many people in the know (like NVida and ATI) as being just as fast?

 

2. Windows Vista failed because there wasn't supposed to be a Vista?

Is this like Letterman saying "no number 2, writer stuck on Jet Blue?" Microsoft has been talking about a subscription based model for a long time. Will they get there? I don't know, but I expected to hear something about Windows Live Mesh. That seems to be some coherent concept moving in that direction. I wouldn't say they dropped it, they are just slow at getting there. I'm not neccesarily defending them here, but I say again, how is this a reason Vista failed (your words, not mine).

 

1. It broke too much stuff

You mean it broke some stuff. And some of that was due to wating on vendors to upgrade drivers. Since you are focusing on enterprise again for this point, isn't it always the case that enterprises don't adopt right away because they know it takes time? How is this any different than any other release of Windows with enterprise wide adoption?

 

Bottom Line:

You said "Microsoft needs to abandon the strategy of releasing a new OS every 3-5 years and simply stick with a single version of Windows and release updates, patches, and new features on a regular basis." So maybe we could all be running Windows 95 with 13 years of patches from Windows Update? Cool. Sign me up.


Read and post comments | Send to a friend

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Apple TV - Recover from nothing Take 2

Ok, so I have updated this for Take 2 and Leopard. This is more of a rought draft, but it worked well for me. Please comment if I have missed any steps since I am writing this after the fact. One big change from the original article us you can let Disk Utility do some of the work for you now. Also, I just skipped the restore partition to keep it simple since that was the source of many problems. Connect your Apple TV drive in Leopard. Remember disk1 may not be the name of your drive. From the terminal: Wipe out and re-create the partition structure sudo diskutil unmountDisk /dev/disk1 sudo gpt destroy /dev/disk1 sudo gpt create /dev/disk1 Create the OSBoot Partition sudo gpt add -b 888872 -i 3 -s 1843200 -t hfs /dev/disk1 diskutil unmountDisk /dev/disk1 sudo diskutil eraseVolume "Journaled HFS+" OSBoot /dev/disk1s3 diskutil unmountDisk /dev/disk1 Create the Media Partition Go to Disk Utility and format the Media partition - Name i
Read more

Convert a LiveCycle Form back to an Acrobat Form

Image
PDF Forms that were saved with Adobe LiveCycle cannot be programatically filled and flattened using most API's, like ActivePDF. However, you can convert your LiveCycle PDF form back into a static PDF. 1. Open the form in LiveCycle and save it as Adobe Static PDF form. (Example using Acrobat X Pro) 2. Download PDFTK  http://www.pdflabs.com/tools/pdftk-the-pdf-toolkit/ 3. Remove extra XML data with the following command line. I copied the creditApplication.pdf file to the same folder. "pdftk creditApplication.pdf output test.pdf drop_xfa" 4. Now you can open the form in Acrobat and rename the forms fields. By default, the conversion might append form[0] stuff to the field names, so I rename them. 5. Save the new PDF using "Save As". Choose "Adobe PDF Files, Optimized (*.pdf)" and in the optimizer window, make it compatible with Acrobat 4.0 and later. 6. You now have a form fillable PDF that you can use programatically and will flatten properly. [gallery
Read more

Converting a MySQL database to SQLite on a Mac

Image
I recently decided to migrate an e-commerce shopping cart system I have been developing for a long time from MySQL to SQLite. I went back and forth over this idea, but I decided it made sense to have an e-commerce shopping cart that the user can install by literally dropping the folder into the site. In order to make the transition as easy as possible, I decided to try to convert the database rather than re-create the many tables and fields needed to make it all work. During my research I found some paid products and a bunch of scripts scattered around, many in Perl. I was looking for something simple that I could try out with minimal effort. I found a script posted at http://www.jbip.net/content/how-convert-mysql-sqlite that worked like a charm for me. I use a Macbook Pro running Snow Leopard. I develop using a local MySQL database and Apache using  MAMP . In order to get started, you need to do a MySQL dump of your database (in t
Read more